Alireza Firouzja bounced back from losing to Magnus Carlsen to
beat world no. 2 Fabiano Caruana in another Armageddon, admitting that by the
end he was “only looking at the clock”. Magnus meanwhile won his first game of
classical chess since March, but his now 124-game unbeaten streak had been in
danger and he described what he did against compatriot Aryan Tari as “a bit too
risky”. Levon Aronian caught Fabi in the lead after squeezing a win out of
nowhere against a luckless Jan-Krzysztof Duda.
You can replay all the Altibox Norway Chess games using the
And here’s the day’s live commentary from Judit Polgar and
Tari 0-1 Carlsen
There was no question that Magnus Carlsen would be out for
blood against his 21-year-old compatriot Aryan Tari, but the World Champion
admitted he’d gone a bit too far in their first ever classical game. 17…d5!? 18.exd5 exf5!?, giving himself tripled
isolated f-pawns, was truly asking for trouble, even if Kramnik had
once done something similar in a World Championship match!
A former World Championship challenger, English GM Nigel
Short, felt it had all been justified…
…but Magnus himself wasn’t so sure.
I think the opening was a decent gamble, but after that it
was a bit too risky. Certainly the choice paid off in the end, but I feel like
his position was a little bit too good at some point… I was just trying to stay
was a move that had our commentators puzzled…
…but it was only after 22…Bd7
that things suddenly fell apart for White. “The thing about the white position
is that it’s extremely good, but you have to win it somehow, and this is what
he was trying to do,” said Magnus, and he wasn’t surprised by what followed.
Moving the bishop to d7 temporarily frees the f4-knight from the need to defend
the d5-pawn, and Aryan “took advantage” of that to play 23.Nh5?, a “knight to the rim” move that the watching Kramnik said
simply wouldn’t have occurred to a more classically trained player.
The move 23.b4 suggested by the commentators, or the
computer’s plan of 23.d6! and 24.Qc3 (or 23.Qc3! first), would have been strong for White, but in the game Magnus was able to counterattack with 23…Nc4! 24.Bxc4 bxc4 25.Qc3?! Rb8! 26.Rf3?
(26.Nxf5 is the move Aryan needed to play, but it was already grim) and
suddenly Magnus got to play perhaps the move of the tournament so far.
Magnus had seen the 26…Re1!
blow in advance, but said, “it was something I was only dreaming of, to be
honest – I didn’t expect it to happen!” There was nothing better than 27.Rxe1
Bxd4 28.Qb4 Qc7 29.d6 Qc6 30.Qa5 and even though 30…Bxb2!? wasn’t the computer’s
first choice of how to finish the job, Magnus showed that the line he played
was powerful, with everything forced until the stylish 34…Qd4!
That was the move being discussed when Kramnik and Polgar told
Aronian about how Magnus had said earlier in the confessional that his bishop
pair was a big long-term asset, if the game lasted that long.
Tari took the a6-pawn with check (35.Ng3 may have offered
some more resistance) allowing Magnus to finish things off with some nice chess
geometry until resignation came on move 45.
The world champion had lived dangerously but is right back on
track, not just picking up a first classical win but becoming the only player
to have won all three mini-matches so far.
Firouzja ½ – ½ Caruana (Alireza wins in Armageddon)
17-year-old Alireza Firouzja had lost on time in Armageddon
the day before to Magnus Carlsen, but the World Champion joined the chorus of
observers who noted that the Iranian has been hugely impressive so far in
Coming off that tough loss to the world no. 1 and then
having to play the world no. 2 is as hard as it gets, but Alireza gave as good
as he got against Fabiano Caruana. The classical game was a sharp, messy affair at first most notable for a knight square in the centre…
It then suddenly came to a surprise end when both players had just over 5 minutes on
Fabi used his g5-break a couple of moves earlier to play the
surprise queen manoeuvre 31…Qb6 32.Kg2 Qg6, impressing Levon Aronian on
the live commentary, but it turned out that was just the start of a repetition of
moves after 33.Kg1 Qb6 and so on. Fabi had considered breaking with f5, but
concluded that was “too risky and it would turn into some complete mess in
So it was another Armageddon game for Firouzja, and once
again things went his way early on. Under the influence of online chess, Vladimir Kramnik described Caruana taking on d7 with his queen as a mouse-slip!
Fabi later agreed:
Qd7 was horrible – I just basically lose two tempi because I
have to reposition my queen and get the knight to d7. It was just a terrible
move. I probably shouldn’t have gone for this line anyway, because why create
such a messy position from the start when it’s just playing into his hands?
Magnus Carlsen was on our live show during the game and commented
of the chaotic position, “I would bet on Alireza here!” before shortly
afterwards the game did indeed swing in the youngster’s favour after 29…Rd8?
It turned out Black had to play 29…Re8 on the previous move,
since now, as Magnus spotted instantly, 30…Qc6 runs into 31.Qxe5!, a double
threat of giving mate on g7 and taking the c5-knight. “Fabiano is going to get
tricked to the moon here!” Magnus added, but 30…f6 ensured the game at least went on,
and by the end a repeat of the previous day was very possible. Back then Alireza had lost
on time after failing to make a move with 5 seconds on his
clock, and this time he got down to 4 seconds at one point. He was a very
relieved man when Fabiano finally resigned.
I got the experience that I should not lose on time only – I
was only looking at the clock! It was difficult at the end for him to somehow
find a way to complicate things – my play is very easy.
After a perfect 6/6 Fabiano had only scored 1 point in Round
3, allowing Levon Aronian to make his move.
Duda 0-1 Aronian
There was again only one Armageddon game in Round 3, which
was remarkable considering Jan-Krzysztof Duda’s classical game against Levon
Aronian looked certain to end in a draw.
Duda had played a quiet variation of the Four Knights in an
obvious bid to end the bleeding after two losses in a row. It seemed a
reasonable idea, but Levon felt it might have been tough for a player like
Definitely my opponent is not having a great tournament, so
I thought today he was trying to play a safe draw. But I think at some point,
because this is not really Jan-Krzysztof’s style, because he’s a very combative
player, I think he was maybe not feeling so comfortable playing for a draw with
White in such an obvious way, and maybe that helped me. But you can never know
what goes through your opponent’s mind.
When Jan-Krzysztof began to hesitate, Levon told himself, “ok,
stop the temptation to agree to a draw”, and when he got to play 34…a4 he already had some hopes.
It should still have ended in a draw, but Levon noted
another factor – the fast time control with no extra time at move 40 benefits the side with the advantage. Kramnik and Aronian both criticised Duda for
playing too passively with his rooks, and when we were down to 7 pieces on the
board at move 49 the tablebases were already showing it was mate-in-42 (!) for
Black. Rook endings are tough, however, and 51…Rh7 (51…Rh5! was objectively the
only win) gave one last chance for White:
52.a4! followed by a5 and it turns out White has just enough
counterplay to save the game, but after 52.Rb6 e3! there was no longer any
salvation, with resignation following 9 moves later.
“An unexpected victory?” asked Kramnik, to which Levon
quipped, “my every victory is unexpected!” The Armenian no. 1 has now caught
Fabiano Caruana in first place, but with 3 points for a classical win there’s
basically nothing to choose between the top 4 players.
The good news for Tari and Duda is that they play each other
in Round 4, while all eyes will be on what Kramnik called El Classico, Carlsen
vs. Caruana. Fabi was asked about the game.
I’ve played so many games against Magnus that it’s difficult
to know what to say. We’ve played a whole match so we know each other pretty well
as players, so it should be an interesting game.
Don’t miss that game, while Aronian-Firouzja will also be
critical to deciding who goes into the first rest day in the lead! Tune in again to Vladimir Kramnik and Judit Polgar, live here on chess24 from 17:00 CEST.