Fabiano Caruana and Anish Giri caught Alireza Firouzja in
the Tata Steel Masters lead after beating Radek Wojtaszek and Maxime
Vachier-Lagrave respectively in Round 9. While Fabi won in unconventional but
convincing style, Anish admitted he was just hanging on in the middlegame, but
a 3rd Najdorf loss in the row for Maxime saw the Frenchman bottom of the table and out of
the world top 10. Magnus Carlsen bounced straight back from the loss to Andrey
Esipenko to defeat Nils Grandelius and move within a point of the lead.
You can replay all the games from Round 9 of the Tata Steel
Chess Masters using the selector below.
And here’s the day’s live commentary from Peter Leko, Jan
Gustasfson and now Lawrence Trent.
Don’t miss the chance to Go Premium with the code TATA2021, which gives you 40% off all of our memberships!
Wojtaszek 0-1 Caruana
7…Bg4!?, only the 9th most popular move in the position, was
a sign that world no. 2 and defending champion Fabiano Caruana had come
prepared to treat the King’s Indian Defence he played against Radek Wojtaszek a
That was nothing compared to what he did with the other
bishop, however, giving up the supposedly critical g7-bishop for the knight on
c3. Seasoned grandmasters were shocked…
…as was Radek.
Fabiano was asked if Ivan did need to go on a refresher course
on how to play chess.
I think that these positions are sort of a bit different
than we knew in the past. The whole King’s Indian has a lot of potential that
we didn’t realise, and I didn’t know if Bxc3 was correct in this position
exactly, but I’d seen it in some similar positions where White can’t really
free himself. If he gets g3, Bg2 basically Black’s position is completely
awful, but he never gets it.
A shocked Wojtaszek spent 30 minutes on 15.Qc1!? and met 15…Nc5
with 16.Qb1!?, a queen manoeuvre that Fabiano felt couldn’t be the correct way
to play. Black soon seized the initiative and crashed through as the time control
approached, with Radek’s decision to accept a piece sacrifice looking suicidal.
Perhaps he wanted to get things over with quickly, and if so
it was a wish Fabi granted.
Giri 1-0 MVL
Maxime Vachier-Lagrave had lost his last two games with
Black after playing the Najdorf, but he wasn’t going to back down and chose his
beloved opening again. At first that decision looked to be vindicated, as
despite Anish Giri pushing an early g4-g5 it was Black who emerged on top. Then
Maxime couldn’t resist a thematic exchange sacrifice:
20…Rxc3!? 21.bxc3 d5 22.exd5?! left White an exchange and a
pawn up, but after 22…Bf5! 23.Qd2 Bd6 Peter Leko stopped sitting on the fence
and felt it had to be Black who had all the chances.
Anish didn’t disagree.
I think he played very well at some point and sacrificed an
exchange and got beautiful positional compensation for the exchange and the pawn,
and I was just trying to hold on, I was just trying to defend at some point. I
don’t think White can ever be better with such a horrible king, and I was just
hoping that I’m not going to get mated right away.
It just hasn’t been Maxime’s tournament, however, and a
couple of inaccuracies in a row suddenly saw him in deep trouble, with 40…Rd8 coming at just the wrong moment.
With 50 minutes added to his clock, Giri could take a
leisurely 17 minutes before deciding to go for the ending after 41.Rxd6! Qxd6
42.Qxf7+ Kh8 43.Qf6+! Qxf6 44.gxf6. Anish said that he felt it should still be
a draw, but computers disagree, and the way the Dutch no. 1 went on to convert
his advantage seemed close to flawless.
Giri is up to world no. 7 and, as co-leader, in with a real
chance of winning his first Masters in Wijk aan Zee, while Maxime has gone the
other way. The Candidates Tournament leader has now plummeted out of the Top 10
and, as you can see, could easily drop further still.
Another player who was suffering was World Champion Magnus
Carlsen, but after seven games without a win he finally struck back in Round 9.
Carlsen 1-0 Grandelius
“Probably more interesting than good”, is how Magnus
described this game, with the curiosities beginning with 6.Qd3!?, the 17th most
popular 6th move against the Najdorf.
Nils Grandelius thought 13 minutes on his reply, and soon
seemed on the ropes, but as the game wore on the Swedish no. 1 came within a
whisker of equalising completely. He never quite got there, but then 30.f4?! by
Magnus could have let him off the hook.
With just over a minute left on his clock, Nils spent 22
seconds before playing the compliant 30…Qd8?, when after 31.Rxe5 Rxb2 32.Rxc5 he
was simply a pawn down in a heavy piece ending.
Magnus’ trick is of course that 30…exf4 runs into mate with 31.Re8#,
but Nils could have met that with 30…c4!, and after 31.Qxc4 it is possible to
play 31…exf4 now that the king can escape to h7 after 32.Re8+.
“I managed to pull myself together at the end and finish it
off quite nicely”, said Magnus, and although the conversion dragged on long
enough for Peter Leko to spend 10 minutes demonstrating a staggering knowledge
of 90s WWF…
…it was a study-like end:
59.Kh5! Qxh3+ 60.Kg6 established complete control at the
cost of a mere pawn, with the game lasting just five more moves.
Afterwards Magnus felt Esipenko had played well in the game
he lost to him, while it was only the failure to beat Duda that he felt was “inexcusable”.
The remaining games were all drawn, with frontrunner Jorden
van Foreest frustrated to get nothing against bottom-placed Alexander
Donchenko, while Tari-Duda was an uneventful draw between two players with
little to play for.
The other key game of the round was the first meeting
between Alireza Firouzja and Andrey Esipenko, which was tense but never caught
fire. One of the moments when it might have done was after 15.b4.
15…g5!? would force White to sacrifice a piece on g5, but
that might just have played into Alireza’s hands. As he commented afterwards:
I think it’s a very dangerous line. The computer gives a
plus for Black but it’s a very dangerous line in a practical game.
Anton-Harikrishna was another game without too much at
stake, but it featured a very memorable position.
It’s not often you see a king coming out to support a piece
so early in the game and with danger all around, but David Anton had it all
It’s a bit strange, but actually I think it’s very safe.
Black doesn’t have any ideas against the king.
In the end, however, he was unable to convert his advantage
and is still hunting a first win.
That means we have three leaders, two players just half a
point off the pace, and Magnus only a point back, with four rounds still to go.
In Wednesday’s Round 10, the day before the final rest day,
we have the most anticipated match-up in chess, between world no. 1 Carlsen and
no. 2 Caruana. In this case there’s even more at stake than usual, with Magnus
knowing a win would suddenly make a huge difference to his tournament
Firouzja will also no doubt go all-out to win with Black vs.
Grandelius, while Giri has White vs. a struggling Wojtaszek. You don’t want to